Airbnb May Be Its Own Worst Enemy

Just two years ago, Airbnb was all about compromise. In several of its biggest markets, including London, Amsterdam, and New Orleans, the home-sharing company agreed to enforce local limits on short-term rentals. The rentees on its platform would only be able to book their listings for, in some cases, 60 days a year. Airbnb Inc. even dropped its legal fight with New York City, saying it would work together with city officials to crack down on hosts operating illegal hotels.

So much for playing nice. These days, Airbnb is battling New York in three separate court cases over how far the city can go to police rentals. Disputes in California and Florida could set broad precedents on the power of Airbnb and other companies in the so-called sharing economy to push back against local governments and landlords. If Airbnb isn’t quite as pugnacious as Uber Technologies Inc. was under Travis Kalanick, some city officials say it’s becoming harder to tell the difference, and that they’re finding Airbnb tougher to work with by the day.